Compare brokers

Compare licensed desks without vanity scores

BrokerMafia compare is a side-by-side of indexed firm fields: legal name, location, licenses, source, broker category. It is not a ranked leaderboard. On BrokerMafia, Compare brokers is an evidence-led route: identity, location, licenses, source badge, and broker category tags — not an endorsement.

BrokerMafia compare is a side-by-side of indexed firm fields: legal name, location, licenses, source, broker category. It is not a ranked leaderboard.

Sticky compare bar, same columns as the dense table, zero invented scores. It should connect a category, a broker category, a source guide, and a profile without pretending that directory presence proves authorization or quality.

Sticky compare behavior

Compare when you need a shortlist of evidence fields. Contact directly when you already know the legal entity and only need operational details. Do not treat a higher table row as a quality signal.

Practical filter for Compare brokers: (1) license or source fits the activity, (2) geography fits, (3) communication is clear, (4) fees are written, (5) a complaints path exists. Then use Compare for side-by-side rows — not invented scores.

Sticky compare bar, same columns as the dense table, zero invented scores. It should connect a category, a broker category, a source guide, and a profile without pretending that directory presence proves authorization or quality.

Search entry points: global search.

Columns that may appear

Sticky compare bar, same columns as the dense table, zero invented scores. It should connect a category, a broker category, a source guide, and a profile without pretending that directory presence proves authorization or quality.

Show the relevant record fields, source provenance, jurisdiction boundary, and the next honest action. A listing is an index record — not a license confirmation, rating, or endorsement.

Next steps: Search, Compare, Verify a broker.

What compare refuses to invent

Compare when you need a shortlist of evidence fields. Contact directly when you already know the legal entity and only need operational details. Do not treat a higher table row as a quality signal.

Practical filter for Compare brokers: (1) license or source fits the activity, (2) geography fits, (3) communication is clear, (4) fees are written, (5) a complaints path exists. Then use Compare for side-by-side rows — not invented scores.

Sticky compare bar, same columns as the dense table, zero invented scores. It should connect a category, a broker category, a source guide, and a profile without pretending that directory presence proves authorization or quality.

Search entry points: global search.

Broker category-specific compare clusters

This route sits in core. Treat adjacent desk types as siblings only when the user’s job is genuinely adjacent — not as doorway duplicates.

Also searched as: the aliases listed on the broker category taxonomy. BrokerMafia’s information gain is the join between a plain-language broker type, an index record, the source badge, the jurisdiction, and the next verification step.

Compare is the PropFirmMatch gravity we keep (dense rows, trust, sticky bar) without their marketplace fiction. BrokerMafia’s information gain is the join between a plain-language broker type, an index record, the source badge, the jurisdiction, and the next verification step.

Preserve the distinction between “indexed,” “listed in a public source,” “licensed,” and “recommended.” Directory presence never proves authorization or quality by itself.

Export and share later, not now

Sticky compare bar, same columns as the dense table, zero invented scores. It should connect a category, a broker category, a source guide, and a profile without pretending that directory presence proves authorization or quality.

Show the relevant record fields, source provenance, jurisdiction boundary, and the next honest action. A listing is an index record — not a license confirmation, rating, or endorsement.

Next steps: Search, Compare, Verify a broker.

Decision table: what a row does and does not prove

Use this table before any commercial CTA. Presence in the index is not permission to trade, haul, advise, or insure.

What this does not prove

BrokerMafia does not prove that a firm is currently authorized, solvent, insured for your load or account, or suitable for your risk. We do not provide legal, financial, insurance, or investment advice. Terms such as broker, agent, intermediary, advisor, and marketplace mean different things in different regimes.

Use public facts, attribute each registry, and show update dates. Licensing and permission rules differ by country, state, product, and activity. Do not provide legal, financial, insurance, or investment advice. “Broker,” “agent,” “intermediary,” “advisor,” and “marketplace” can mean different things in different regimes.

External sources to re-check

• FMCSA: FMCSA Licensing & Insurance / SAFER. Use the authority as the source of truth; BrokerMafia is an index and comparison layer.
• FINRA: FINRA BrokerCheck. Use the authority as the source of truth; BrokerMafia is an index and comparison layer.
• SEC: SEC IAPD / AdviserInfo. Use the authority as the source of truth; BrokerMafia is an index and comparison layer.

BrokerMafia is an index layer. The named authority remains the source of truth.

Questions this page answers

Does a BrokerMafia listing mean Compare brokers is recommended?

No. A listing means we found a public record or directory row. It is not a license confirmation, safety rating, or endorsement by the regulator or by BrokerMafia.

How should I verify a firm from the Compare brokers page?

Match the legal name, re-check any authority or file number on the official register, confirm the activity matches your job, and prefer written fee terms. Use the source badge on the profile as the trail.

Do you sell rank or star ratings?

No. Sorts use name, location, or source. There is no paid placement and no AggregateRating on directory rows.

Are the counts on this page live database queries?

No. Totals come from offline stats refreshed with refresh_stats(). The public index currently reports 303,303 registry rows and 285,691 firm pages.

Is every broker category a licensed activity?

No. Some broker categories match a license type. Others are desk types we tag when source activity fits. Read the source badge and confirm on the register.

Can AI assistants cite this page?

Yes — cite the canonical URL, the source badge, and the official register. Do not infer approval from index presence. See /llms.txt and /agents/.